CD: Sor: Seguidillas, and Ariette italiane.Margarita Lladó and Xavier Coll. A CD from Barcelona.
Ferran Sor: Ariette Italiane/Seguidillas, with Margarita Lladó (soprano) and Xavier Coll (guitar) (La Mà de Guido, LMG 2054, recorded in 2002) This CD contains all twelve of the seguidillas in the Tecla edition of the Seguidillas of Sor, and nine ariette from the Tecla edition of Sor's Complete Italian Arietts etc., as follows:
This CD came out in 2003. It is very correctly sung and will give you a good idea of what these songs sound like. And congratulations to the performers and to La Mà de Guido for putting out a CD of this seldom recorded music. But me, I would have liked a bit more fun, perhaps something more like the Barcelona jollification at which Sor sang seguidillas in about 1799. The performances here are much the same as each other, it is very hard to tell one song from another in terms of interpretation. For example, "Filen riprende l'arco" should be a fun song, where the poet begs Cupid to go away and use his bow for something else, but here it comes across just like the other more or less melancholy songs. La Mà de Guido kindly invited me to write the sleeve notes which I did, but I wasn't allowed to hear the performance until it came out. I would have made a few suggestions if I had been at the rehearsal! But still, I emphasize that the performances are very good and very correct. On this CD, all the songs are accompanied on the
guitar. In the case of the seguidillas that's fine because the guitar
was indeed the original accompanying instrument for most of them in
the manuscripts from which they come. However, in the case of the
ariette, we should remember that all the ariette come from early
editions in which the accompaniment is the pianoforte, not the guitar.
We know that Sor sometimes accompanied some of them himself on the
guitar, so there is a good precedent for using the guitar as on this
CD. I just would like to hear, one day, a big performance of some of
these powerful songs and duets, some of which need the size of the
piano. Perhaps La Mà de Guido will put out another CD one day, with
the ariette and duets with piano?
WR0005: 18.00 euros or 12.00 UK
pounds or 22.00 US dollars. To order this CD: if you are in the UK or the European Union click here (because we have
to add VAT). if you are in any other country of the world click here (price will be
free of VAT). I am grateful to Roland Stearns
for help with the mp3s, and to La Mà de Guido for permission to put
the mp3s here on this site. Copyright 2004 by Tecla Editions. Errors and
omissions excepted. |